01-22-2007, 10:18 PM
First off, let me say that I think everyone has the perfect right to cast his/her vote based on whatever criteria they want. There are some ways of deciding I think make perfect sense and others I think are ridiculous and sometimes small-minded. But nobody's paying anyone to think my way, are they? When I play Ausserland, the vote is cast strictly on the merits of the resolution. I don't give a flying flip whether it's a repeal or otherwise. I look at what it does. And I've voted for resolutions written by people I considered perfect a------s and against resolutions written by friends. But that's just my way.
What bothers me is that the repeal of "World Heritage List" keeps cropping up as an argument against the whole broad category of repeals. And I think it might be good to separate out motives from tactics in our consideration. I considered the tactics used in that repeal debate to be slimy and underhanded. And old Ausserland said so, loud and clear, in several forums. On the other hand, the motive for the repeal was commendable: to rid the NSUN of a resolution that was badly flawed and provided a mechanism by which nations could legally (if not legitimately) harm others. The fact that the author and some supporters chose to use a disreputable tactic (which I happened to consider, for a couple of reasons, a personal affront) didn't change that.
I'd hate to see that unfortunate mess continue to reinforce a generalized suspicion about the motives of the authors of repeals.
What bothers me is that the repeal of "World Heritage List" keeps cropping up as an argument against the whole broad category of repeals. And I think it might be good to separate out motives from tactics in our consideration. I considered the tactics used in that repeal debate to be slimy and underhanded. And old Ausserland said so, loud and clear, in several forums. On the other hand, the motive for the repeal was commendable: to rid the NSUN of a resolution that was badly flawed and provided a mechanism by which nations could legally (if not legitimately) harm others. The fact that the author and some supporters chose to use a disreputable tactic (which I happened to consider, for a couple of reasons, a personal affront) didn't change that.
I'd hate to see that unfortunate mess continue to reinforce a generalized suspicion about the motives of the authors of repeals.