PASSED: Repeal "UN Educational Committee"
#13
FoD Before you were here or right when you arrived, there was a mass of repeals and some of them were for good reasons. However they almost always claimed that they had a better resolution in development but never did.[/quote]
One did. The repeal of World heritage List. The others didn't make such claim; and in the case of Repeal "Sexual Freedom", there was a replacement written. So this whole overreaction is based on one repeal. Just so we're clear on that.
Quote: I came to find out that some of the groups sponsoring repeals were actually just trying to remove as much UN influence as possible from our NS world.[/quote]
Not true. That group was seeking any means to strike out one of the most damaging resolutions the UN has ever passed. I didn't agree with the tactic but I can understand why they thought people might not realize just how catastrophic the resolution potentially was, given the spectacular failure of this region, supposedly home to more thoughtful and considered debates, to do so.

I can understand your annoyance at that repeal - I was annoyed at it, to the point I voted against it and then copped several rounds of shit for doing so. But please don't write off all repeals on the basis of it (well, maybe not quite all); and please don't slander the intentions of a region that have contributed more resolutions to the UN than any other, except yours. They don't want to 'remove as much UN influence as possible': they wanted to remove a resolution that allowed any nation to list any site, of zero environmental significance, in any other nation, and prohibit all economic activity within it. Maybe we could all do with a touch of perspective.
Quote: Since I believe in the NSUN, I felt offended and frustrated by this. my thought was, if they don't want to be subject to the rules of the UN, then resign. What these groups want are all the benefits of UN membership but they don't want to be subject to the majority will.[/quote]
Yeah, here's the thing. Repeals require more votes for than against to pass. By passing a repeal, they were part of the majority will.

And there was no benefit to UN membership associated with World heritage List, only crippling detriment.
Quote: In this case, if it is repealed then so be it because I do agree that it is not as good as it could be but I won't contribute my vote to that end because I've made the decision that a poorly written resolution is better than no resolution at all.[/quote]
But it's not no resolution at all! We already have one - UN Educational Aid Act. If we repeal this, we still have a resolution on an educational committee.
Grosseschnauzer Quod, for those of us who hav been around longer, such as me and Mik, we've known Hersfold for a long time, and he is a friend of the IDU,[/quote]
I know hersfold. he's a a jumped up, hypersensitive, self-important prick with zero rational judgement and less capacity for criticism. But I don't care: I'll judge his resolutions by their merits, not the fact they're by him.

This being exactly my point. Resolutions should be judged on their text: being by a nice guy doesn't guarantee their quality; having the word 'repeal' in the title doesn't vouch against it. Nobody has raised any objection to a single line of this repeal. Instead, this region that supposedly prides itself on contributing to the UN constructively and productively is running and hiding because their friend wrote the resolution. Please. We have an opportunity to strike out an utterly worthless resolution, remove a useless committee, and make a statement that resolutions should be clear in meaning and action, and not ridiculous sub-adolescent slurry. Why are we so afraid of having the UN doing something like that?

Presumably because your pal is simultaneously a wonderful, reasonable individual good relations with whom is of significant import, and a whiny brat who'll fly off the handle at his precious resolution having some nasty words said about it. With friends like these...
Reply


Messages In This Thread

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)