World Assembly: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| (28 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{Infobox geopolitical organization | {{Featured article}}{{Infobox geopolitical organization | ||
| | |conventional_long_name = World Assembly | ||
|native_name = <!-- Long-form name in native or any/all non-English languages --> | |native_name = <!-- Long-form name in native or any/all non-English languages --> | ||
|linking_name = <!-- For wikilinks, if diff from name --> | |linking_name = <!-- For wikilinks, if diff from name --> | ||
|image_flag = | |image_flag = waflag.svg | ||
|alt_flag = Flag of the World Assembly | |alt_flag = Flag of the World Assembly | ||
|flag_border = <!--set to no to disable border around the flag--> | |flag_border = <!--set to no to disable border around the flag--> | ||
| Line 22: | Line 22: | ||
|org_type = Intergovernmental Organisation | |org_type = Intergovernmental Organisation | ||
|membership_type = <!-- (default "Membership") --> | |membership_type = <!-- (default "Membership") --> | ||
|membership = | |membership = 22,090 | ||
|admin_center_type = <!-- e.g. "Administrative center" (default) --> | |admin_center_type = <!-- e.g. "Administrative center" (default) --> | ||
|admin_center = <!-- Location/s of administrative center/s --> | |admin_center = <!-- Location/s of administrative center/s --> | ||
|languages_type = Official Language(s) | |languages_type = Official Language(s) | ||
|languages = English | |languages = English | ||
|leader_title1 = Secretary-General | |leader_title1 = Secretary-General | ||
|leader_name1 = ''In Commission''<br/>{{resize|80%|currently held by the Secretariat}} | |leader_name1 = ''In Commission''<br/>{{resize|80%|currently held by the [[World Assembly Secretariat|WA Secretariat]]}} | ||
|leader_title2 = <!-- e.g. "Deputy chair", etc. --> | |leader_title2 = <!-- e.g. "Deputy chair", etc. --> | ||
|leader_name2 = | |leader_name2 = | ||
| Line 76: | Line 76: | ||
}} | }} | ||
The '''World Assembly''' ('''WA''') is a voluntary world governing body, and an intergovernmental organisation tasked with creating and enforcing a body of laws that all member states must abide by. It is also responsible for some border disputes, and for praising or admonishing individual nations and/or regions. The World Assembly is the successor to the [[United Nations]], which was dissolved on 06 April 2008. There are currently c. | The '''World Assembly''' ('''WA''') is a voluntary world governing body, and an intergovernmental organisation tasked with [[World Assembly resolution|creating and enforcing a body of laws]] that all member states must abide by. It is also responsible for some border disputes, and for praising or admonishing individual nations and/or regions. The World Assembly is the successor to the [[United Nations]], which was dissolved on 06 April 2008.<ref name=wa>https://www.nationstates.net/page=WA_past_resolution/id=1/council=1</ref> There are currently c.22,090 nations that are member states of the body, with c.950 of those nations also acting as regional Delegates. The organisation is financed by assessed donations from its member states. Of all voluntary governing bodies that exist, the WA is one of the largest, international, and powerful. | ||
The World Assembly was created on 01 April 2008 immediately prior to the dissolution of the United Nations; legislation officially creating the body was passed on 06 April. When creating the new organisation it was decided that, though all members of the UN would automatically be considered members of the WA, the body of laws that had been curated since the founding of the UN six years previously would be cleared and that member states would be free to establish, or re-establish, new or previously existing laws. This decision was met with vocal opposition at the time and membership in the body dipped significantly. Though no concessions were given to opponents, membership gradually began to climb again once a period of adjustment to the new body had passed. | The World Assembly was created on 01 April 2008 immediately prior to the dissolution of the United Nations; legislation officially creating the body was passed on 06 April.<ref name=wa/> When creating the new organisation it was decided that, though all members of the UN would automatically be considered members of the WA, the body of laws that had been curated since the founding of the UN six years previously would be cleared and that member states would be free to establish, or re-establish, new or previously existing laws.<ref name=wa/> This decision was met with vocal opposition at the time and membership in the body dipped significantly. Though no concessions were given to opponents, membership gradually began to climb again once a period of adjustment to the new body had passed. | ||
The WA is divided into two chambers: the [[General Assembly]], which is responsible for the body of laws created and enacted by the WA, and the [[Security Council]], which regulates the behaviour and actions of individual member states and/or their regions through non-binding resolutions. A number of WA agencies - sometimes referred to as Committees - also operate, and their establishment and functions are regulated by the General Assembly; such examples include the General Accounting Office, the World Assembly Adoption Authority, and the World Health Authority. Another noteworthy WA agency is the Compliance Commission, which ensures all laws passed by the organisation are enforced in member states. | The WA is divided into two chambers: the [[General Assembly (World Assembly)|General Assembly]], which is responsible for the body of laws created and enacted by the WA, and the [[Security Council (World Assembly)|Security Council]], which regulates the behaviour and actions of individual member states and/or their regions through, for the most part, non-binding resolutions. A number of [[World Assembly Agencies|WA agencies]] - sometimes referred to as Committees - also operate, and their establishment and functions are regulated by the General Assembly; such examples include the General Accounting Office, the World Assembly Adoption Authority, and the World Health Authority. Another noteworthy WA agency is the Compliance Commission, which ensures all laws passed by the organisation are enforced in member states. | ||
The WA is led by a Secretary-General, a position that is currently held in commission by the World Assembly Secretariat (referred to as the Secretariat), the civil service that staffs all chambers and agencies; this should not be confused with the the General Assembly Secretariat (referred to as the GA Secretariat), however, which only acts as | The WA is led by a [[World Assembly Secretariat#Secretary-General|Secretary-General]], a position that is currently held in commission by the [[World Assembly Secretariat]] (referred to as the Secretariat), the civil service that staffs all chambers and agencies; this should not be confused with the the [[World Assembly Secretariat#General Assembly Secretariat|General Assembly Secretariat]] (referred to as the GA Secretariat), however, which is a part of the Secretariat, but only acts as the General Assembly's rules committee - currently six member states serve on that committee. | ||
==History== | ==History== | ||
===Establishment=== | ===Establishment=== | ||
At some point during the night of 31 March and 01 April 2008, a major [[wikipedia:natural disaster|natural disaster]] occurred at the [[United Nations]] Headquarters in sovereign UN territory. While no casualties were reported at that time, significant and irreparable damage to the infrastructure of the building, as well as the surrounding terrain, rendered the area unsafe and uninhabitable. In response to the assessment of the situation by the UN leaders, the nation of [[Maxtopia]] proposed that a replacement international governing body be formed and that UN be disestablished. | At some point during the night of 31 March and 01 April 2008, a major [[wikipedia:natural disaster|natural disaster]] occurred at the [[United Nations]] Headquarters in sovereign UN territory.<ref> https://www.nationstates.net/page=news/2008/03/31/index.html</ref> While no casualties were reported at that time, significant and irreparable damage to the infrastructure of the building, as well as the surrounding terrain, rendered the area unsafe and uninhabitable. In response to the assessment of the situation by the UN leaders, the nation of [[Maxtopia]] proposed that a replacement international governing body be formed and that UN be disestablished. | ||
Initial responses to the Maxtopian delegation's proposal were muted with some cautious support, as many representatives initially understood the proposed measure to be temporary only until the UN Headquarters could be salvaged and re-fit to be suitable for purpose. However as the debate continued - in temporary lodgings procured for the continuation of UN business - it became increasingly clear to the delegations present that the Maxtopian proposal intended for the replacement body, the World Assembly, to not only be permanent in nature, but to also wipe clean the books of international law and, in the words of one sympathetic Ambassador, "start fresh". | Initial responses to the Maxtopian delegation's proposal were muted with some cautious support, as many representatives initially understood the proposed measure to be temporary only until the UN Headquarters could be salvaged and re-fit to be suitable for purpose. However as the debate continued - in temporary lodgings procured for the continuation of UN business - it became increasingly clear to the delegations present that the Maxtopian proposal intended for the replacement body, the World Assembly, to not only be permanent in nature, but to also wipe clean the books of international law and, in the words of one sympathetic Ambassador, "start fresh". | ||
| Line 92: | Line 92: | ||
Ambassadors that initially treated the proposal with cautious support or indifference began to vocally criticise and oppose the Maxtopian proposal, with some delegations actually resigning their nation from the international organisation in protest. Within a relatively quick timeframe, however, the proposal did make it to the floor as a resolution to be considered. Debate during the vote was later documented to be "vicious" and "passionate", with many opponents expressing condemnation that the hitherto good work of the body in creating and curating international law would all have been for nothing. As voting continued over the next number of days, it became clear that the Maxtopian proposal to abolish the United Nations and its laws was gathering widespread support from smaller and independent-minded nations and delegations. | Ambassadors that initially treated the proposal with cautious support or indifference began to vocally criticise and oppose the Maxtopian proposal, with some delegations actually resigning their nation from the international organisation in protest. Within a relatively quick timeframe, however, the proposal did make it to the floor as a resolution to be considered. Debate during the vote was later documented to be "vicious" and "passionate", with many opponents expressing condemnation that the hitherto good work of the body in creating and curating international law would all have been for nothing. As voting continued over the next number of days, it became clear that the Maxtopian proposal to abolish the United Nations and its laws was gathering widespread support from smaller and independent-minded nations and delegations. | ||
The United Nations was formally abolished on 6 April 2008 with almost 84% of member states voting in favour of the resolution. The World Assembly was officially established upon the votes end, though it was confirmed that its official 'creation date' was 1 April 2008, and that all member states that were members of the UN were now members of this new body. It was further clarified that the vote undertaken to establish the World Assembly would be considered the first vote in, and resolution of, the WA itself. | The United Nations was formally abolished on 6 April 2008 with almost 84% of member states voting in favour of the resolution.<ref name=wa/> The World Assembly was officially established upon the votes end, though it was confirmed that its official 'creation date' was 1 April 2008, and that all member states that were members of the UN were now members of this new body. It was further clarified that the vote undertaken to establish the World Assembly would be considered the first vote in, and resolution of, the WA itself. | ||
===Expansion=== | ===Expansion=== | ||
On 27 May 2009, a year on from the organisation's creation, the Secretariat announced that following a review of internal rules, member states of the World Assembly would be free to pass non-binding resolutions expressing favour, or lack thereof, on other nations and regions, including those who were not members of the organisation itself. These non-binding resolutions, referred to by the Secretariat as Resolutions to Commend or Condemn, almost immediately caused consternation among more established and traditionalist delegations. It also attracted criticism from non-member states of the World Assembly, accusing the body of interfering in nations that do not involve themselves in the voluntary organisation. | On 27 May 2009, a year on from the organisation's creation, the Secretariat announced that following a review of internal rules, member states of the World Assembly would be free to pass non-binding resolutions expressing favour, or lack thereof, on other nations and regions, including those who were not members of the organisation itself.<ref>https://www.nationstates.net/page=news/2009/05/27/index.html</ref> These non-binding resolutions, referred to by the Secretariat as Resolutions to Commend or Condemn, almost immediately caused consternation among more established and traditionalist delegations. It also attracted criticism from non-member states of the World Assembly, accusing the body of interfering in nations that do not involve themselves in the voluntary organisation. | ||
After a significant number of delegations protested that such resolutions would be a significant deviation from the law-making expertise and tradition the body had, the Secretariat announced on 8 June that it would be creating a second chamber, the [[Security Council]], that would be tasked with the debates and enactment of the Resolutions to Commend or Condemn. The original chamber would be renamed the [[General Assembly]]. It was clarified at the time of this announcement that member states of the World Assembly would be members of, and entitled to votes in, both chambers. | After a significant number of delegations protested that such resolutions would be a significant deviation from the law-making expertise and tradition the body had, the Secretariat announced on 8 June that it would be creating a second chamber, the [[Security Council (World Assembly)|Security Council]], that would be tasked with the debates and enactment of the Resolutions to Commend or Condemn. The original chamber would be renamed the [[General Assembly (World Assembly)|General Assembly]]. It was clarified at the time of this announcement that member states of the World Assembly would be members of, and entitled to votes in, both chambers. | ||
===Further changes=== | |||
Since the 2009 expansion of powers of the World Assembly, the Secretariat has, with the consent of member states, on three occasions added further powers to the World Assembly, more specifically the Security Council. First in June of 2009, the power to bindingly resolve border disputes, called Liberations, were added to the decision-making portfolio of member states. This addition was not without controversy, with some member states objecting to the Security Council being given binding powers after a period of only non-binding resolutions, but the majority of member states were happy to proceed. | |||
In 2021, a new non-binding power called Declarations were added to the roster of options.<ref>https://www.nationstates.net/page=news/2021/07/08/index.html</ref> This allowed members of the Security Council to propose resolutions that reflected the opinion of the body on regional or international matters. The addition of this power was greatly welcomed by the body's members, with few detractors. Some criticised the power for potentially allowing the Security Council to indirectly legislate on matters, which is a reserved power for the General Assembly, however it was stressed by the Secretariat during the proposing of the new power that these would be non-binding only, and any resolutions that looked liked legislation would not be permitted to be put to vote, and member states proposing such would be directed to the General Assembly. | |||
After years of consultation with the member states, the World Assembly announced a cosmetic refresh in 2023, consisting of a more "modernised" flag for the body as a whole, as well as a new flag for each of the General Assembly and the Security Council.<ref>https://www.nationstates.net/page=news/2023/04/18/index.html</ref> In addition, the Security Council received a further new resolution type, with the new binding option of Injunctions. This power allows the World Assembly to intercede in regional security situations and block, where the body sees necessary, regions (both geographic and organisational) from adjusting their regional security protocols. This new power attracted some contention during its proposal stage, but negotiations between Secretariat and member states led to compromises being made by both sides, and the final extent of the power being agreeable to most. | |||
==Structure== | ==Structure== | ||
===Secretariat=== | ===Secretariat=== | ||
:''Main Article: [[World Assembly Secretariat]]'' | |||
The World Assembly Secretariat is headed by the [[World Assembly Secretariat#Secretary-General|WA Secretary-General]], occupancy of which is currently held in commission by the Secretariat as a whole. Comprising of civil servants from around the world, the Secretariat oversees the day-to-day running of the World Assembly, its chambers, its agencies, and the execution and implementation of any decisions made by those bodies. | |||
The Secretariat acts as the final arbiter in any internal disputes between member states, including having the power to suspend and/or expel member states who continuously act in disregard of the body's rules. While individual delegations are responsible for the drafting and submission of pieces of legislation, the Secretariat may be called upon to determine the legality of such proposals - in the General Assembly this responsibility is under the purview of [[World Assembly Secretariat#General Assembly Secretariat|General Assembly Secretariat]], a sub-committee of the Secretariat that acts as that chamber's rules committee; unlike the Secretariat as a whole, the General Assembly Secretariat is made up of six member states selected by the Secretariat. | |||
Generally seen as reliably impartial, the Secretariat has in the past attracted some criticism by members of the World Assembly for often delaying on rules and/or legality challenges. Other criticisms have included claims that the Secretariat are often too narrow-minded in rules interpretation, and that their decisions often suggest they are out of touch with member states of the World Assembly. | |||
===General Assembly=== | ===General Assembly=== | ||
:''Main Article: [[General Assembly (World Assembly)|General Assembly]]'' | |||
The General Assembly (GA) is the main deliberatively body of the World Assembly. It meets in a continuous session at the WA Headquarters building, located in sovereign and inviolable WA territory. The GA has no designated President or leader, though the Secretariat are the enforcers of decorum when necessary. A sub-committee of the Secretariat, the GA Secretariat, is also present in this chamber and are considered the arbiters of the legality of proposals made by delegations. Six member states currently sit on the GA Secretariat; original appointments were made by the Secretariat and all subsequent vacancies are filled by a vote of the GA Secretariat themselves. | |||
The GA is made up of thirteen different committees, through which delegations propose and debate different resolutions. Proposed resolutions that make it to the floor to vote, however, are voted upon by the entire World Assembly. | |||
Each resolution at vote is allocated ninety-six hours to achieve a simple majority of votes cast in favour to become a binding resolution. Resolutions that do not meet this threshold are not considered passed. Occasionally resolutions may meet the threshold of a majority of votes cast in favour, however the GA Secretariat may decide to discard the vote's results if they find the resolution in question falls foul of legality rules and conventions. | |||
===Security Council=== | ===Security Council=== | ||
:''Main Article: [[Security Council (World Assembly)|Security Council]]'' | |||
The Security Council (SC) is charged with spreading interregional peace and goodwill, as well as the resolution of contested regional border disputes. Like the GA, it also meets in a continuous session at WA Headquarters, and as with the GA, all member states of the World Assembly are also members of this Council. Since its creation, however, a number of notable members of the World Assembly have mounted very public boycotts of the Security Council refusing to take part in its sessions and vote on their proposed resolutions. | |||
Resolutions made by the SC can come in five forms, three of which, Declaration, Commend, and Condemn, are non-binding and are instead general statements of opinion, or statements of praise or displeasure of a nation or region by the World Assembly. The fourth and fifth, Liberations and Injunctions, are binding resolutions of the Security Council pertaining to regional border dispute arbitration and regional security respectively. | |||
As with the General Assembly, the SC has no designated leader of the body, with the Secretariat acting as presiding officers. The Security Council does not have a dedicated rules committee like the General Assembly has with the GA Secretariat; instead the Secretariat themselves decide when proposals are illegal. | |||
===Agencies=== | ===Agencies=== | ||
:''Main Article: [[World Assembly Agencies]]'' | |||
Agencies, committees, and other organisations may be created by the General Assembly via resolutions in order to execute the particulars of a given piece of legislation. All WA agencies are staffed by the Secretariat, with its civil servants drawn internationally from a diverse range of backgrounds. Some of the better known agencies of the World Assembly include the [[World Health Authority]], the [[WA Scientific Programme]], and the [[International Humanitarian Aid Coordination Committee]]. | |||
The GA may, by passage of a resolution, vote to disband agencies or organisations, however skeleton staff of the agencies may remain to execute policies set forth by other extant resolutions. | |||
==Membership== | ==Membership== | ||
Membership in the World Assembly is entirely optional and, indeed, most nations in existence do not maintain membership in the body. As there is a high turnover in nations being admitted to, and being expelled or resigning from, the World Assembly, it is impossible to give an accurate number of nations in the body at any one time; April 2023 estimates, however, put it around 22,100 nations. | |||
There are two tiers of membership in the World Assembly - regular member state status, and regional delegate status; the usage of regional delegates means that each [[region]] is also represented in the World Assembly, not just individual nations. Each member state has one vote in each the General Assembly and the Security Council. Regional delegates, however, have a voting power of [number of member states in their region endorsing/supporting them] + [their own one vote]. | |||
In practice, this means that individual nations in regions can decide to endorse or support the nation designated, by internal regional means, as their regional delegate. This endorsement or support, however, tends to be completely option for member states and there is no World Assembly-mandated requirement that a member state should endorse or support their regional delegate. Nations that do choose to endorse their regional delegate still maintain their own separate vote, however the nation that is the regional delegate gains an extra vote for every nation that does decide to endorse or support them. | |||
This tiered membership, combined with the voting power afforded to the regional delegates, has attracted significant controversy and opposition over the years; the most common complaint about the system is that regions that have a large population of WA member-states have an inflated vote count which is therefore unfair on smaller regions. Various reforms have been presented by member states to the Secretariat, though to date no suggestion has gained traction with the WA leadership. | |||
==References== | |||
<references /> | |||
[[Category:World Assembly]][[Category:Politics]][[Category:Organisations]] | |||
Latest revision as of 15:36, 23 May 2023
World Assembly | |
|---|---|
| Official Language(s) | English |
| Type | Intergovernmental Organisation |
| Membership | 22,090 |
| Leaders | |
• Secretary-General | In Commission currently held by the WA Secretariat |
| Establishment | |
• Creation | 01 April 2008 |
• Ratification | 06 April 2008 |
Website www.nationstates.net/un | |
The World Assembly (WA) is a voluntary world governing body, and an intergovernmental organisation tasked with creating and enforcing a body of laws that all member states must abide by. It is also responsible for some border disputes, and for praising or admonishing individual nations and/or regions. The World Assembly is the successor to the United Nations, which was dissolved on 06 April 2008.[1] There are currently c.22,090 nations that are member states of the body, with c.950 of those nations also acting as regional Delegates. The organisation is financed by assessed donations from its member states. Of all voluntary governing bodies that exist, the WA is one of the largest, international, and powerful.
The World Assembly was created on 01 April 2008 immediately prior to the dissolution of the United Nations; legislation officially creating the body was passed on 06 April.[1] When creating the new organisation it was decided that, though all members of the UN would automatically be considered members of the WA, the body of laws that had been curated since the founding of the UN six years previously would be cleared and that member states would be free to establish, or re-establish, new or previously existing laws.[1] This decision was met with vocal opposition at the time and membership in the body dipped significantly. Though no concessions were given to opponents, membership gradually began to climb again once a period of adjustment to the new body had passed.
The WA is divided into two chambers: the General Assembly, which is responsible for the body of laws created and enacted by the WA, and the Security Council, which regulates the behaviour and actions of individual member states and/or their regions through, for the most part, non-binding resolutions. A number of WA agencies - sometimes referred to as Committees - also operate, and their establishment and functions are regulated by the General Assembly; such examples include the General Accounting Office, the World Assembly Adoption Authority, and the World Health Authority. Another noteworthy WA agency is the Compliance Commission, which ensures all laws passed by the organisation are enforced in member states.
The WA is led by a Secretary-General, a position that is currently held in commission by the World Assembly Secretariat (referred to as the Secretariat), the civil service that staffs all chambers and agencies; this should not be confused with the the General Assembly Secretariat (referred to as the GA Secretariat), however, which is a part of the Secretariat, but only acts as the General Assembly's rules committee - currently six member states serve on that committee.
History[edit | edit source]
Establishment[edit | edit source]
At some point during the night of 31 March and 01 April 2008, a major natural disaster occurred at the United Nations Headquarters in sovereign UN territory.[2] While no casualties were reported at that time, significant and irreparable damage to the infrastructure of the building, as well as the surrounding terrain, rendered the area unsafe and uninhabitable. In response to the assessment of the situation by the UN leaders, the nation of Maxtopia proposed that a replacement international governing body be formed and that UN be disestablished.
Initial responses to the Maxtopian delegation's proposal were muted with some cautious support, as many representatives initially understood the proposed measure to be temporary only until the UN Headquarters could be salvaged and re-fit to be suitable for purpose. However as the debate continued - in temporary lodgings procured for the continuation of UN business - it became increasingly clear to the delegations present that the Maxtopian proposal intended for the replacement body, the World Assembly, to not only be permanent in nature, but to also wipe clean the books of international law and, in the words of one sympathetic Ambassador, "start fresh".
Ambassadors that initially treated the proposal with cautious support or indifference began to vocally criticise and oppose the Maxtopian proposal, with some delegations actually resigning their nation from the international organisation in protest. Within a relatively quick timeframe, however, the proposal did make it to the floor as a resolution to be considered. Debate during the vote was later documented to be "vicious" and "passionate", with many opponents expressing condemnation that the hitherto good work of the body in creating and curating international law would all have been for nothing. As voting continued over the next number of days, it became clear that the Maxtopian proposal to abolish the United Nations and its laws was gathering widespread support from smaller and independent-minded nations and delegations.
The United Nations was formally abolished on 6 April 2008 with almost 84% of member states voting in favour of the resolution.[1] The World Assembly was officially established upon the votes end, though it was confirmed that its official 'creation date' was 1 April 2008, and that all member states that were members of the UN were now members of this new body. It was further clarified that the vote undertaken to establish the World Assembly would be considered the first vote in, and resolution of, the WA itself.
Expansion[edit | edit source]
On 27 May 2009, a year on from the organisation's creation, the Secretariat announced that following a review of internal rules, member states of the World Assembly would be free to pass non-binding resolutions expressing favour, or lack thereof, on other nations and regions, including those who were not members of the organisation itself.[3] These non-binding resolutions, referred to by the Secretariat as Resolutions to Commend or Condemn, almost immediately caused consternation among more established and traditionalist delegations. It also attracted criticism from non-member states of the World Assembly, accusing the body of interfering in nations that do not involve themselves in the voluntary organisation.
After a significant number of delegations protested that such resolutions would be a significant deviation from the law-making expertise and tradition the body had, the Secretariat announced on 8 June that it would be creating a second chamber, the Security Council, that would be tasked with the debates and enactment of the Resolutions to Commend or Condemn. The original chamber would be renamed the General Assembly. It was clarified at the time of this announcement that member states of the World Assembly would be members of, and entitled to votes in, both chambers.
Further changes[edit | edit source]
Since the 2009 expansion of powers of the World Assembly, the Secretariat has, with the consent of member states, on three occasions added further powers to the World Assembly, more specifically the Security Council. First in June of 2009, the power to bindingly resolve border disputes, called Liberations, were added to the decision-making portfolio of member states. This addition was not without controversy, with some member states objecting to the Security Council being given binding powers after a period of only non-binding resolutions, but the majority of member states were happy to proceed.
In 2021, a new non-binding power called Declarations were added to the roster of options.[4] This allowed members of the Security Council to propose resolutions that reflected the opinion of the body on regional or international matters. The addition of this power was greatly welcomed by the body's members, with few detractors. Some criticised the power for potentially allowing the Security Council to indirectly legislate on matters, which is a reserved power for the General Assembly, however it was stressed by the Secretariat during the proposing of the new power that these would be non-binding only, and any resolutions that looked liked legislation would not be permitted to be put to vote, and member states proposing such would be directed to the General Assembly.
After years of consultation with the member states, the World Assembly announced a cosmetic refresh in 2023, consisting of a more "modernised" flag for the body as a whole, as well as a new flag for each of the General Assembly and the Security Council.[5] In addition, the Security Council received a further new resolution type, with the new binding option of Injunctions. This power allows the World Assembly to intercede in regional security situations and block, where the body sees necessary, regions (both geographic and organisational) from adjusting their regional security protocols. This new power attracted some contention during its proposal stage, but negotiations between Secretariat and member states led to compromises being made by both sides, and the final extent of the power being agreeable to most.
Structure[edit | edit source]
Secretariat[edit | edit source]
- Main Article: World Assembly Secretariat
The World Assembly Secretariat is headed by the WA Secretary-General, occupancy of which is currently held in commission by the Secretariat as a whole. Comprising of civil servants from around the world, the Secretariat oversees the day-to-day running of the World Assembly, its chambers, its agencies, and the execution and implementation of any decisions made by those bodies.
The Secretariat acts as the final arbiter in any internal disputes between member states, including having the power to suspend and/or expel member states who continuously act in disregard of the body's rules. While individual delegations are responsible for the drafting and submission of pieces of legislation, the Secretariat may be called upon to determine the legality of such proposals - in the General Assembly this responsibility is under the purview of General Assembly Secretariat, a sub-committee of the Secretariat that acts as that chamber's rules committee; unlike the Secretariat as a whole, the General Assembly Secretariat is made up of six member states selected by the Secretariat.
Generally seen as reliably impartial, the Secretariat has in the past attracted some criticism by members of the World Assembly for often delaying on rules and/or legality challenges. Other criticisms have included claims that the Secretariat are often too narrow-minded in rules interpretation, and that their decisions often suggest they are out of touch with member states of the World Assembly.
General Assembly[edit | edit source]
- Main Article: General Assembly
The General Assembly (GA) is the main deliberatively body of the World Assembly. It meets in a continuous session at the WA Headquarters building, located in sovereign and inviolable WA territory. The GA has no designated President or leader, though the Secretariat are the enforcers of decorum when necessary. A sub-committee of the Secretariat, the GA Secretariat, is also present in this chamber and are considered the arbiters of the legality of proposals made by delegations. Six member states currently sit on the GA Secretariat; original appointments were made by the Secretariat and all subsequent vacancies are filled by a vote of the GA Secretariat themselves.
The GA is made up of thirteen different committees, through which delegations propose and debate different resolutions. Proposed resolutions that make it to the floor to vote, however, are voted upon by the entire World Assembly.
Each resolution at vote is allocated ninety-six hours to achieve a simple majority of votes cast in favour to become a binding resolution. Resolutions that do not meet this threshold are not considered passed. Occasionally resolutions may meet the threshold of a majority of votes cast in favour, however the GA Secretariat may decide to discard the vote's results if they find the resolution in question falls foul of legality rules and conventions.
Security Council[edit | edit source]
- Main Article: Security Council
The Security Council (SC) is charged with spreading interregional peace and goodwill, as well as the resolution of contested regional border disputes. Like the GA, it also meets in a continuous session at WA Headquarters, and as with the GA, all member states of the World Assembly are also members of this Council. Since its creation, however, a number of notable members of the World Assembly have mounted very public boycotts of the Security Council refusing to take part in its sessions and vote on their proposed resolutions.
Resolutions made by the SC can come in five forms, three of which, Declaration, Commend, and Condemn, are non-binding and are instead general statements of opinion, or statements of praise or displeasure of a nation or region by the World Assembly. The fourth and fifth, Liberations and Injunctions, are binding resolutions of the Security Council pertaining to regional border dispute arbitration and regional security respectively.
As with the General Assembly, the SC has no designated leader of the body, with the Secretariat acting as presiding officers. The Security Council does not have a dedicated rules committee like the General Assembly has with the GA Secretariat; instead the Secretariat themselves decide when proposals are illegal.
Agencies[edit | edit source]
- Main Article: World Assembly Agencies
Agencies, committees, and other organisations may be created by the General Assembly via resolutions in order to execute the particulars of a given piece of legislation. All WA agencies are staffed by the Secretariat, with its civil servants drawn internationally from a diverse range of backgrounds. Some of the better known agencies of the World Assembly include the World Health Authority, the WA Scientific Programme, and the International Humanitarian Aid Coordination Committee.
The GA may, by passage of a resolution, vote to disband agencies or organisations, however skeleton staff of the agencies may remain to execute policies set forth by other extant resolutions.
Membership[edit | edit source]
Membership in the World Assembly is entirely optional and, indeed, most nations in existence do not maintain membership in the body. As there is a high turnover in nations being admitted to, and being expelled or resigning from, the World Assembly, it is impossible to give an accurate number of nations in the body at any one time; April 2023 estimates, however, put it around 22,100 nations.
There are two tiers of membership in the World Assembly - regular member state status, and regional delegate status; the usage of regional delegates means that each region is also represented in the World Assembly, not just individual nations. Each member state has one vote in each the General Assembly and the Security Council. Regional delegates, however, have a voting power of [number of member states in their region endorsing/supporting them] + [their own one vote].
In practice, this means that individual nations in regions can decide to endorse or support the nation designated, by internal regional means, as their regional delegate. This endorsement or support, however, tends to be completely option for member states and there is no World Assembly-mandated requirement that a member state should endorse or support their regional delegate. Nations that do choose to endorse their regional delegate still maintain their own separate vote, however the nation that is the regional delegate gains an extra vote for every nation that does decide to endorse or support them.
This tiered membership, combined with the voting power afforded to the regional delegates, has attracted significant controversy and opposition over the years; the most common complaint about the system is that regions that have a large population of WA member-states have an inflated vote count which is therefore unfair on smaller regions. Various reforms have been presented by member states to the Secretariat, though to date no suggestion has gained traction with the WA leadership.
References[edit | edit source]
- ↑ a b c d https://www.nationstates.net/page=WA_past_resolution/id=1/council=1
- ↑ https://www.nationstates.net/page=news/2008/03/31/index.html
- ↑ https://www.nationstates.net/page=news/2009/05/27/index.html
- ↑ https://www.nationstates.net/page=news/2021/07/08/index.html
- ↑ https://www.nationstates.net/page=news/2023/04/18/index.html