"Mikitivity" And yes, I'm very weary of any party that labels itself "Christian" ... but she seemed to be getting some interesting press coverage.[/quote]
Well, the Christian Democratic Union is one of the two major parties here, similar to the Tories in the UK or the Republicans in the US.
Quote: Are [German ballots] different in different states?[/quote]
No, the principle is the same everywhere. But... See below. ;-)
The ballot you can see above shows the "first vote" candidates for constituency #296, and the "second vote" party lists for the state of Saarland. Let me explain...
"Mikitivity" I'm looking at the ballot, which is incredibly interesting. There are two sides, but you can vote for parties on the second side, right? Why is Lore Muller not on side one too? How do German ballots work and are they different in different states?[/quote]
There are currently 299 constituencies, and Parliament has 598 seats. The constituencies all have about the same population. The candidate who receives most "first votes" (the black part on the left) in her/his constituency becomes a Member of Parliament. A simple majority is enough (e.g. 40% vs. 30% vs. 30%). That's how 299 of the 598 seats (exactly 50%) are elected.
With the "second vote" (the blue part on the right), you choose a political party, not a person. The proportion of seats in parliament corresponds to the proportion of second votes.
If a party wins 80 constituencies (from the first votes) and gets 20% of the second votes, it will get about 120 seats in parliament (20%). These 120 seats will be the 80 directly elected MPs plus 40 people from the party's list. Every party has such a list. If a person is high on a list, s/he needn't win a constituency. One such case is the premier of my state (Peter M?ller, CDU). He doesn't candidate in any constituency, but he has a secure party list place.
If another party wins 70 constituencies, but only gets 10% of the second votes, things become more complicated. The 70 people who won a constituency have a guaranteed seat in parliament. But since the party only deserves about 60 seats (10%), it won't get any additional MPs from its list. This surplus of seats (compared to the proportion) become the party's "overhang mandates", which finally lead to Parliament having more than 598 seats.
I hope that was comprehensible. Because in reality it's even more complicated. ;-)
First, there's the "5% obstacle". A party with less than 5% of the second votes won't enter parliament unless it won three constituencies.
Germany consists of 16 states. The lists I mentioned are not nationwide, but only statewide. Though the implications are very different from the American system. Say a party gets lots of votes in Bavaria and Saxony, but virtually none in the others, and it wins 10 constituencies. Assume this party gets a total of 10% nationwide. Then the party will have 10% of the seats in parliament. 10% is about 60 seats. 10 MPs have won their seats directly, the other 50 come from the party's lists. But which list? The answer is simple: Bavaria and Saxony because those were the states where the party was strongest. Candidates from other state's lists will be ignored then.
Let's have another example, because I don't think this was comprehensible.
Second Vote Results:
SPD 33%, CDU 30%, Left 10%, CSU 8%, Greens 7%, FDP 7%, NPD 3%, other parties 2%
CSU is the Bavarian branch of CDU, so those votes come from one state only.
Assume The Left's has strong support in the eastern states, a bit in NRW and Saarland, virtually nothing in the other states.
Assume further that the Greens and the FDP are virtually insignificant in the east.
First Vote Results:
CDU 190, SPD 60 constituencies, CSU 40 constituencies (all of Bavaria except for Munich), Left 9 constituencies
Analyzing the second votes:
NPD and the other parties all have less than 5%, so they don't count.
We would then have the following number of seats:
SPD 208, CDU 189, Left 63, CSU 50, Greens 44, FDP 44 (total: 598)
Overhang mandates:
The CDU has won 190 constituencies, but they only deserve 189 seats. So their 190th will be an overhang mandate.
Revised number of seats:
SPD 208, CDU 190, Left 63, CSU 50, Greens 44, FDP 44 (total: 599)
Members of Parliament:
All first vote winners plus party list candidates:
SPD 60+148, CDU 190+0, Left 9+54, CSU 40+10, Greens 0+44, FDP 0+44
State party lists:
SPD: Assuming they have about the same proportion in all states, the 148 seats will be divided among the 16 state lists following their sizes. So, in addition to the 60 directly won constituencies, we will have about 30 social-democratic MPs from NRW, 20 from BaW?, 2 from Saarland etc.
CDU: They already have more than they deserve. No state party list seats for them.
Left: With the assumptions above, the would get about 2/3 of their seats from the eastern states and 1/3 from NRW, because NRW has about as many inhabitants as all eastern states combined.
CSU: 40 directly elected MPs, 10 from the Bavarian state list.
Greens and FDP: 44 candidates from western state lists. Maybe 12 MPs from NRW, 4 from Hessen, 2 from Hamburg.