07-03-2005, 03:20 AM
Oh, I've really been out of it; missing a flag AND civil rights discussion! So as a really late entry, here's my contribution:
I love flags, but if somebody wants to burn their own, get a permit for it (it is a fire hazard, and may cities ban the burning of leaves inside city limits) and go ahead if you must. However, as a tactic, it is a failure unless your goal is to inflame (pun intended) opinion AGAINST your position. It is, in effect, a negative position.
In the 1991 Gulf War, campus peaceniks at the university I occasionally attended ran anti-Coalition and/or anti-US rallies which desecrated but didnot burn flags. The pro-war contingent held a pro-UN rally, waving the UN flag as positive measure. Very effective I thought. Who would think that 12 years later we would yearn for a good war like Gulf I (actually Gulf II, but that's another issue).
In North America, many cities don't have flags. The N.A. Vexillogical Association did a survey a few months ago on the prettiest and ugliest of about 150 U.S. civic flags. Chicago rated highly (I believe in the top 3), and for good reason. Others rated very poorly, typically because they were way to busy and had lettering crammed into them.
The city where I was raised was recently forcibly amalgamated with its suburbs. One of the few good things to come from it was they dropped the old civic flag (which probably would have ranked in the bottom quartile of the U.S. city flags survey) for a very nice one. Check out my puppet "Hamilton Ontario."
So better late than never.
I love flags, but if somebody wants to burn their own, get a permit for it (it is a fire hazard, and may cities ban the burning of leaves inside city limits) and go ahead if you must. However, as a tactic, it is a failure unless your goal is to inflame (pun intended) opinion AGAINST your position. It is, in effect, a negative position.
In the 1991 Gulf War, campus peaceniks at the university I occasionally attended ran anti-Coalition and/or anti-US rallies which desecrated but didnot burn flags. The pro-war contingent held a pro-UN rally, waving the UN flag as positive measure. Very effective I thought. Who would think that 12 years later we would yearn for a good war like Gulf I (actually Gulf II, but that's another issue).
In North America, many cities don't have flags. The N.A. Vexillogical Association did a survey a few months ago on the prettiest and ugliest of about 150 U.S. civic flags. Chicago rated highly (I believe in the top 3), and for good reason. Others rated very poorly, typically because they were way to busy and had lettering crammed into them.
The city where I was raised was recently forcibly amalgamated with its suburbs. One of the few good things to come from it was they dropped the old civic flag (which probably would have ranked in the bottom quartile of the U.S. city flags survey) for a very nice one. Check out my puppet "Hamilton Ontario."
So better late than never.