06-25-2005, 07:27 PM
I don't believe that burning flags should be illegal. I echo much of what has been stated here.
Flags do have a lot of symbolism that is concretely important to many people. Putting meaning in symbols is, not to overgeneralize, a universal human trait.
A healthy pride in one's nation or locale is not problematic, and it serves to foster a sense of community (community in the sense of social connections, rather than a geographical location).
Its hard to know where to draw the line when nationalism becomes problematic. I would venture that extreme nationalism is quite severe in the world right now, which has violent consequences.
The push to protect the flag is not a new issue, and I personally see the issue being brought up at this particular time as suspect. We are in a war, and people's emotions are brought to a heightened sense. I think that trying to legislate against burning the flag will only serve to alienate us from each other, as well as send a negative message to our neighbors.
The government is supposed to not infringe on our personal freedoms or liberties. Along those lines I ask this question:
What liberty do we have (as Americans for the sake of this question) do we have? Do we really have liberty, or are we only permitted to engage in activities that our government allows?
Flags do have a lot of symbolism that is concretely important to many people. Putting meaning in symbols is, not to overgeneralize, a universal human trait.
A healthy pride in one's nation or locale is not problematic, and it serves to foster a sense of community (community in the sense of social connections, rather than a geographical location).
Its hard to know where to draw the line when nationalism becomes problematic. I would venture that extreme nationalism is quite severe in the world right now, which has violent consequences.
The push to protect the flag is not a new issue, and I personally see the issue being brought up at this particular time as suspect. We are in a war, and people's emotions are brought to a heightened sense. I think that trying to legislate against burning the flag will only serve to alienate us from each other, as well as send a negative message to our neighbors.
The government is supposed to not infringe on our personal freedoms or liberties. Along those lines I ask this question:
What liberty do we have (as Americans for the sake of this question) do we have? Do we really have liberty, or are we only permitted to engage in activities that our government allows?