Execution may be agonizing
#7
I'm with my northern neighbour Keeslandia. I have wavered on this issue throughout my life (ususual for many people, since it seems to be a deeply ingrained and most emotionally decided issue). I am now very narrowly in favour, with Keeslandia's caveats and conditions.

Now that lethal injection has got a bad reputation, there will be another more "humane" method chosen. Remember, the neck-breaking hanging (opposed to the strangulation hanging), the guillotine, the electric chair and other methods were also supposed to be the humane answer to executions. However, as Groot Gouda notes, no matter how you do it, it's still taking a life. Any supporter of the death penalty has to face up to that, and few are willing to do so, insisting that with the proper technology that all will be well.

(This entirely discounts the issue of wrongful convictions and innocent people being executed, which happens far more often than commonly realized.)

Death penalty opponents rarely admit that not executing people also causes death. Murderers with no conscience can and do kill again. Check out several gruesome British examples on the regular Wikipedia, notably John Straffen and Rober Maudsley:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whole_life_tariff

Or try Allan Legere:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allan_Legere


So you have to weigh the lives of the executed guilty murders and the executed innocents against the lives of prison inmates, prison guards and people unluckly enought to be around when murderers escape. It's not an easy decision to make, but it is one that we should consciously make. So how many innocent people executed are innocent people not murdered worth? That's the question.
Reply


Messages In This Thread

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)