08-26-2005, 03:33 AM
OOC - IRL I am a parliamentarian (as in, professionally trained to chair meetings according to parliamentary procedure, not as in a member of parliament), so poorly worded resolutions in general antagonise me. So, for that reason I support the repeal. On principle, bad resolutions should be repealed and replaced by good ones. In my experience chairing groups, committees, and organisations a poorly crafted resolutions always creates unintended harm. That harm can frequently be greater in magnitude than the intended benefit. Having said that, the NSUN would be immeasurably improved with a repeal and replace mechanism that was done in one motion. If people had an alternative with which they were immediately presented, then they might be able to better appreciate difference in quality, leading to greater support for better crafted resolutions.
IC - The Holy and Serene Republic respects the views of the members of the IDU, but lends its support to the views expressed by Groot Gouda. Lloegr-Cymru will vehemently support, regardless of the outcome of this repeal, the upcoming resolution to protect all animals regardless of species.
IC - The Holy and Serene Republic respects the views of the members of the IDU, but lends its support to the views expressed by Groot Gouda. Lloegr-Cymru will vehemently support, regardless of the outcome of this repeal, the upcoming resolution to protect all animals regardless of species.

