08-15-2005, 09:22 AM
Antrium, there are several problems I notice with your resolution.
First, there is too much detail of the process that you would impose. When Tejasdom put forth the original idea for a Tsunami Warning System, the draft contained way too much detail about the way the system would work -- it even described distances from shorelines and details about the type of sensors that would be used. It's not necessary for the UN Gnomes, it serves no purpose in how each player's rating in the different categories are affected, and with the most recent guidelines for drafting proposals posted by Hack over at the Jolt forums, it might well be the kiss of death.
Second problem is, not just the invaison of privacy issue cited by Groot Gouda, but it raises a serious question as to the real object of the concept. In RL, many states and localities are imposing bans of 2500 feet (1/2 mile) from any school, park, day care center, etc., which in many places effectively bans the person from even living in a urban or suburban area, and all but deprives them in many places of being able to legally have a residence.
The other questions is whether this is being directed towards sex offenders who target adults or children. Not all sex offenders have the same inclination as to the categories of their victims, and the recent spate of well publicized cases in the US have been for the most part in response to pedophiles more than anything else. The other legislative trend that is troubling is the tendency to required convicted sex offenders to remain in prison even after they have completed their sentences until it is possible for a medicial certification to be made that they have been "fully treated" (read "cured
of their violent sexual behavior.
You know, the issues that come up in NS about sending rapists to slave labor or executing them -- that is about what the legal trand is for real.....so you need to ask yourself how broad or how narrowly you really intend this proposal to be, and adjust it accordingly.
I don;t know that I would necessarily vote fot this, but I thought I would mention some things to think about in trying to craft a well thought out and written proposal.
First, there is too much detail of the process that you would impose. When Tejasdom put forth the original idea for a Tsunami Warning System, the draft contained way too much detail about the way the system would work -- it even described distances from shorelines and details about the type of sensors that would be used. It's not necessary for the UN Gnomes, it serves no purpose in how each player's rating in the different categories are affected, and with the most recent guidelines for drafting proposals posted by Hack over at the Jolt forums, it might well be the kiss of death.
Second problem is, not just the invaison of privacy issue cited by Groot Gouda, but it raises a serious question as to the real object of the concept. In RL, many states and localities are imposing bans of 2500 feet (1/2 mile) from any school, park, day care center, etc., which in many places effectively bans the person from even living in a urban or suburban area, and all but deprives them in many places of being able to legally have a residence.
The other questions is whether this is being directed towards sex offenders who target adults or children. Not all sex offenders have the same inclination as to the categories of their victims, and the recent spate of well publicized cases in the US have been for the most part in response to pedophiles more than anything else. The other legislative trend that is troubling is the tendency to required convicted sex offenders to remain in prison even after they have completed their sentences until it is possible for a medicial certification to be made that they have been "fully treated" (read "cured
of their violent sexual behavior.You know, the issues that come up in NS about sending rapists to slave labor or executing them -- that is about what the legal trand is for real.....so you need to ask yourself how broad or how narrowly you really intend this proposal to be, and adjust it accordingly.
I don;t know that I would necessarily vote fot this, but I thought I would mention some things to think about in trying to craft a well thought out and written proposal.