Passed:At Vote: Repeal "Stop Privacy Intrusion" - Printable Version

+- IDU Regional Forum (https://idugov.com/forum)
+-- Forum: Government Square (https://idugov.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=101)
+--- Forum: WA Delegate's Bureau (https://idugov.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=24)
+---- Forum: General Assembly Resolutions (https://idugov.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=25)
+---- Thread: Passed:At Vote: Repeal "Stop Privacy Intrusion" (/showthread.php?tid=636)

---

Passed:At Vote: Repeal "Stop Privacy Intrusion" - Eisophca - 05-16-2006

Quote: Repeal "Stop privacy intrusion"

A proposal to repeal a previously passed resolution

Category: Repeal
Resolution: #10
Proposed by: Adolf Barham

Description: UN Resolution #10: Stop privacy intrusion (Category: Human Rights; Strength: Strong) shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

Argument: The United Nations,

UNDERSTANDING the privacy protections in Resolution #10, "Stop Privacy Intrusion,"

CONSIDERING that Resolution #10, "Stop Privacy Intrusion," does not enforce anything due to the wording used in that it only suggests that each UN member passes the legislation, making the resolution ineffectual,

NOTING that Resolution #10, "Stop Privacy Intrusion," severely hampers the ability of governments in the NSUN to catch criminals,

ALSO NOTING that Resolution #10, "Stop Privacy Intrusion," does not define many of the terms it contains, making it vague,

FURTHERMORE NOTING that Resolution #10, "Stop Privacy Intrusion," does not define "other kinds of interception of communications," nor what "serious" evidence of a planned or committed crime means, making it even more vague,

BELIEVING that an improved replacement that doesn't go too far in protecting people's privacy, should be made,

REPEALS Resolution #10 "Stop Privacy Intrusion."

Co-Authored by: Reveal and Repeal[/quote]

---

Passed:At Vote: Repeal "Stop Privacy Intrusion" - Eisophca - 05-16-2006

The resolution is now at vote. I will cast the region's vote on Wednesday or Thursday.

---

Passed:At Vote: Repeal "Stop Privacy Intrusion" - Groot Gouda - 05-16-2006

Bah, a repeal. Against.

---

Passed:At Vote: Repeal "Stop Privacy Intrusion" - Enn - 05-16-2006

I like the original. I don't like Adolf Barham. I don't like Repeal&Replace as an ideology. Hence, AGAINST.

---

Passed:At Vote: Repeal "Stop Privacy Intrusion" - Adam Island - 05-16-2006

The repeal resolution isn't entirely honest - "Stop privacy intrusion" doesn't "suggest" that each NSUN member pass legislation, but proposes it as a binding part of the law.

And if the resolution is so vague, why can't these frustrated law enforcement officials get around it?

I vote AGAINST.

---

Passed:At Vote: Repeal "Stop Privacy Intrusion" - Grosseschnauzer - 05-16-2006

AGAINST

---

Passed:At Vote: Repeal "Stop Privacy Intrusion" - Antrium - 05-16-2006

So, so against.

---

Passed:At Vote: Repeal "Stop Privacy Intrusion" - Keeslandia - 05-16-2006

Given what's happening in the USA, they've GOT to be kidding. Blissfully, we don't have those same issues in the Empire. We're opposed to the repeal.

---

Passed:At Vote: Repeal "Stop Privacy Intrusion" - Eisophca - 05-17-2006

I have voted AGAINST this resolution, per the region's vote.

---

Passed:At Vote: Repeal "Stop Privacy Intrusion" - Eisophca - 05-25-2006

This resolution has passed.

---